Excerpt via Essay:
Yet Spicilège and her family as well sought the intervention of traditional doctors or curanderos. The curandero provides providers that a Traditional western doctor are not able to: the cleaning ceremony reported in the case analyze is a perfect sort of differences in thinking toward medical care. A healing ceremony performed by a curandero is not likely to harm the infant and in fact may prove beneficial at least to the parents’ and family’s peace of mind.
There can be no absolute ethical guidelines in medical care except for the truth that health care workers are obliged constantly to treat people with respect. Respect requires sensitivity to cultural big difference and to the norms define attitudes toward health care. Medical care workers might find that a lot of patients need privacy , nor express emotions; whereas different patients are emotionally expressive to the point where they will shock or perhaps disturb those around them. These issues should be managed using a philosophical underpinning of ethical relativism. Ethical relativism allows health care workers to consider a unattached view that respects patient autonomy. Healthcare services are supplied without any strings attached. The health care member of staff does not impose the dominating culture’s beliefs on the affected person, and the affected person also areas the fact that the hospital is providing services to clients who have cannot pay. This simple fact offers a sort of moral harmony in the case: Spicilège and Hugo are obtaining health care pertaining to humanitarian factors and this understanding precludes these people from searching for further assistance.
A worldview that principles the differences between cultures will not preclude healthcare workers from making decision regarding guidelines. In fact , the idea of moral relativism as well ensures that the nurse or doctor’s values are as valid while those of the individual. If a doctor is absolutely in opposition to a patient’s wish because of different ethical viewpoints, after that that doctor can easily reassign the case to a colleague instead of pass view on the patient.
Ana and Hugo are understandably worried that they will obtain deported if perhaps they decide to apply for any social providers. Their unrecorded status presents a risk that Choix and Hugo assumed after entering the country. While Bêtisier and Hugo need to be well intentioned of American regulation, the health attention workers assisting the friends and family has no directly to interfere. Featuring the best quality of patient proper care possible is definitely the duty and obligation in the health care worker.
Moreover, healthcare workers need to set aside all their belief in ethical absolutism with regards to Ana’s situation. Even if there is a child involved, it is vital to esteem patient autonomy in this case. Spicilège and Hugo are doing what ever they can, and whatever is their means, to help their child. The health proper care workers would all they will could to help Ana, conserve for allowing the presence of the curandero. Choix and Hugo are doing the very best they can within the limitations with their immigration position. At this point, We would advise medical care workers to respect the independence of the couple also to cease interfering with their lives or perhaps the life with the infant. A pluralistic point-of-view acknowledges social differences, respects patient autonomy, and provides the best possible quality of care.
Sources
“Ethical Relativism. ” (2011). Retrieved on the web: http://www.allaboutphilosophy.org/ethical-relativism-faq.htm
“Ethical Relativism, inches (n. g. ). Retrieved online: http://philosophy.lander.edu/ethics/relativism.html
Macklin, 3rd there’s r. (1998). Ethical relativism within a multicultural world. Kennedy Company of Integrity Journal 8, Number 1.
“Neonatal encephalopathy, inch (2011). Baby Services Clinical Guideline. Gathered online: http://www.adhb.govt.nz/newborn/guidelines/neurology/NE.htm
Slick, Meters. Ethical relativism. CARM. Recovered online: http://carm.org/ethical-relativism van Eerden, P. Bernstein, P. H. (2003). Summary of the Syndication, “Neonatal Encephalopathy and Desapasionado Palsy: Determining the Pathogenesis and Pathophysiology, ” by ACOG Process Force upon Neonatal Encephalopathy and Cerebral Palsy. Medscape. Retrieved on-line: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/457882
Velasquez, M., Andre, C. Shanks, Thomas S i9000. J., Meyer, M. J. (1992). Ethical relativism. Father christmas Clara University or college. Retrieved online: http://www.scu.edu/ethics/practicing/decision/ethicalrelativism.html
“What is Moral Relativism? inches Sheldon Chumir Foundation for Ethics in Leadership. Gathered online: http://www.chumirethicsfoundation.ca/main/page.php?page_id=145
