Often in literature, authors unintentionally generate works that tie well with one another. Two works that connect well are The Journey by Homer, translated by simply Robert Fizgerald, and “My Father in the Shield, ” by Walt McDonald. Whilst McDonald’s poem underscores the tone of mourning and sorrow by main figure, Homer’s operate elucidates the tone of animosity and hurt.
As previously stated, the tone of McDonald’s poem, “My Father in the Shield” is usually one of mourning and tremendous grief.
The presenter of the poem is grieving his dad who this individual lost to fight and encounters struggles in coping with all this. McDonald’s details about the sled mentioned in the poem indicate the closeness that was once there involving the speaker great father, as well as the level of importance the speaker’s father experienced in his life. The use of diction by McDonald also highlights the speaker’s mourning, typically accompanied by nostalgia, by implicating the replication of the words and phrases “I remember” throughout the composition.
This constant remembrance expresses the speaker’s difficulty arriving at terms along with his father’s fatality. In contrast with McDonald’s composition, Homer’s function, The Odyssey, exhibits a tone filled more with animosity and heartache rather than the previous, more somber and mournful experience. The main character, thus far, is named Telemakhos. The character’s daddy has been removed for many years with no returning or sending any kind of messages, triggering the young man and his mother to wonder whether he has passed away, or in the event that he is eliminated because he will not wish to returning. By the use of details, readers can find out that as a result of his father’s extended absence, many suitors have got begun to consider free rule over their house and all of their property, seeking to get married to the possible widow. Homer uses diction in order to show the Telemoakhos’ animosity toward his daddy:
Friend, allow me to put it in the plainest approach. My mom says We am his son; I realize notsurely. Who have known his own engendering? I wish at least I had some completely happy man as afather, growing old in his individual house – unknown death and peace and quiet are the destiny of him that, sinceyou ask, they will call my dad. (Homer 8) Telemakhos is saying that although his mom and everyone say Odysseus is his dad, he will not feel that method because he does not have any memory space of him. He desires he could have his dad in his lifestyle, and is irritated by the simple fact he has not the slightest bit of expertise in regards to the whereabouts of his father.
Telemakhos and the presenter in the poem by McDonald share related experiences. That they both are coping with the a shortage of their dads who equally partook in the military. However , the presenter in the poem actually is aware for a fact his father has perished, which may be why he deals with the lack of a dad better than Telemakhos, solely because he does not need to query whether or not his father isn’t very in his your life due to sheer carelessness. Because Telemakhos have not the faintest idea of his father’s location, he is looking for drawing a line under, not only for himself, but also for his mom and real estate being damaged by the savage suitors. Their circumstances will be what control the develop in their discussion, allowing the reader to feel the same things the speakers will be feeling.
1
